Turkey Club Sandwich

As a chef, I like to imagine that my customers are attracted to the most exotic and masterful recipes I concoct from my imagination.

The truth is, most people order the turkey club.

Every day in every restaurant, the chef and manager look at the menu mix, which is a list of all the items sold the previous day listed in order of their popularity. Depending on the restaurant, the number one item is almost always the most pedestrian dish. The fact is, most people just aren’t that adventurous.

In most of the restaurants where I worked, we served breakfast, lunch and dinner. Despite working hard to make sure we offered interesting and inventive items on the menu every day, the number one menu item invariably was either the turkey club or the cheeseburger. These are simply the restaurant facts of life.

So today, I’m going to show you step-by-step instructions on how to make restaurant quality turkey club sandwiches in your own home. Turkey clubs are basically triple decker bacon-lettuce-and-tomato sandwich with turkey. Simple, you say? Ah, there’s always a trick!

First, toast the bread:

Second, spread mayonnaise on all three slices of bread:

Third, place lettuce leaves on two of the three slices of bread:

Then the tomato slices:

Then the turkey:

Then the bacon:

Next, stack the two slices with lettuce, tomato, bacon and turkey on top of each other and top with the third toast slice:

Here’s the trick part. Think of the sanwich as the face of a clock. Put one toopick at 12 o’clock, one at 3 o’clock, one at 6 o’clock, and one 9 o’clock, then square off the sandwich by using a knife to trim away anything hanging over the four outside sides:

Then cut the sandwich in between the toothpicks in an “X” pattern. Normally, I would use frilly toothpicks but at home I did not have any:

Invert the four peices onto a plate with outside of the bread resting on the plate and the sides pointing toward the center of the plate to form a little bowl in the center:

Fill the bowl with potato chips, French fries, cottage cheese or whatever you want. I used oven-baked garlic parmesan fries. Here’s the recipe:

Oven-Baked Garlic Parmesan Fries

2-3 russet potatoes, peeled and cut into fries

2 TBS vegetable oil

1 TBS granulated garlic

1/2 tsp sea salt

1/4 tsp fresh cracked black pepper

1/4 cup grated parmesan

1. Preheat oven to 375F. Place potato sticks in bowl and toss with vegetable oil, granulated garlic, salt and pepper. Lay out on sheet pan, leaving space between each potato stick so that they cook evenly, and bake 40 minutes.

2. Remove from oven, use a spatula to turn a little, sprinkle with parmesan and return to oven for another 10 minutes. These can be made ahead of time and held in a 200F for up to an hour. Serve with ketchup on the side.

Garnish the sandwich with a pickle spear and voila! A restaurant-style turkey club in your own home.

What kind of restaurant favorites would you like to duplicate in your home? Share your ideas in the comments section below. And thanks for looking at my blog!

12 thoughts on “Turkey Club Sandwich

  1. Great fries recipe. I like to do thick potato chips seasoned with lemon pepper salt.

    Even a simple turkey club, made by someone who is focused on making a great sandwich, is a worthy menu item.

      • We have a cheap mandolin, with no waffle blade.
        It also doesn’t have a “slide” adjustment, but adjusts to preset distances. We go with thicker chips, because it won;t go small enough for proper potato chips. A proper one is on my list of toys to get.
        That and a full-on deli slicer. Oh,I would love one of those!

  2. Actually he comes from a Miracle Whip/Hellman’s family. Michael, you’ve been gone too long. Mom is MW; Dad is Hellman’s. But now, you’ve got me craving a turkey club and it’s a very rainy day and no turkey in the house. 😦

    • Reading the comments in my email all day reminded me of a guy I knew who was obsessed with replicating Hellmans recipe.
      He thought it had something to do with the temperature they achieved in the blending process that gave them such a creamy emulsion.
      Obsessed he was…

  3. Pingback: Improving the Cheeseburger | Budget Cooking Blog

  4. Just tried this recipe and found it exactly replicated our cherished club sandwich experiences of places in the Berwyn-Stickney area like Seneca’s or Bill’s Family Restaurant or even Walgreens in Cermak Plaza. With this recipe/assembly instructions in hand, I may never order a club sandwich in a restaurant again.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s